A Thoughtful Match: Replacing a Lost Topaz Earring with a Custom Twin

When it comes to jewelry, even a single earring can hold incredible meaning. That was the case for this client, who came to us with one beautifully cut topaz earring—the last remaining half of a beloved pair. Rather than let it sit unused, she had a creative and thoughtful idea: why not remake the missing earring and bring the set back to life?

Replacing a lost earring might sound simple, but it requires careful attention to detail—especially when working with colored gemstones. Topaz comes in a wide range of hues, and even subtle shifts in tone can make a recreated piece feel mismatched. The challenge here was finding a raw topaz that closely matched the exact shade, cut, and clarity of the existing earring.

Using the original as a reference, we sourced a raw stone and shaped it to mirror the original in size and brilliance. Once the new topaz was cut and polished, we handcrafted a matching setting so that the earrings could feel cohesive and intentional—as if they had always been together.

This kind of custom work is a beautiful way to restore balance to a jewelry collection while honoring what is already there. Whether it’s a meaningful gift or a personal treat, recreating a lost earring is a subtle yet powerful way to give a second life to something you love.

Have a solo earring you just cannot part with? Let’s talk about bringing its match back.